Click Here for More Information
Ukraine Adoption Blog

03/01/06

The Anti-Adoption Crowd: My Emotional Reaction

Posted by : Angela in Ukraine Adoption Blog at 11:59 am , 478 words, 78 views  
Categories: Issues



When I decided to become a parent via adoption in 1999, I asked a friend (who had adopted) for advice on getting started. His reply frankly made me angry because I thought he was just blowing me off.


He told me to read, read, read and then read some more.


I decided to take his advice and I started reading. Can you believe it... google.com was just a beta release in 1999. I used msn.com and yahoo.com to search for adoption information. And I found USENET which later became Google Groups. Strange how the world changes so quickly.


I found people who people thought that adoption should be against the law. Wow... These people are stupid and crazy was my first impression and second impression.


But I kept reading various postings. I found the Australian anti-adoption gang (Origins and Di). I found Lori Carangelo's ABOLISH ADOPTION web site.

SPONSOR
Click Here for More Information


Lori has a new comparsion I see.... She is comparing adoption to terrorism.


I finally figured out why I was reading such bizarre writings of people who obviously needed some serious counseling and maybe some medication. At the root... at the base element of their anti-adoption writing there was some truth.


Adoption is about someone else's pain. Someone else has to lose for me to adopt. But it is not my fault that someone else failed to parent his or her child. And that is the part that rubs me the wrong way. Many anti-adoption folks are so busy trying to discuss the "adoption problem" that they never discuss the real issue.


The problem is that a man and a woman had a baby and cannot parent the child. How about working on issues that prevent this man/woman from parenting? How about lobbying the federal government on changes for the welfare block grants? These grants should be used to provide affordable child care for low income parents. I believe that only 2 states use the money in this manner. Ugh!


Back to the anti-adoption folks.... Maybe they weren't crazy, just really sad and in a great amount of pain. They cannot move past a traumatic event and are stuck to wallow in their pain. So this anti-adoption thing was their way of holding a pity party.


And then I ran into Di (the Origins - Australian Anti-Adoption) on a forum. I read the threads between Di and Adoptees. I started replying to several threads. Some days she would attack me and other days she would be fairly rational.


These discussions helped me realize that the real reason I kept reading the anti-adoption web sites and postings was that I felt threatened. And because I felt threatened I wanted them to be crazy or stupid or mentally ill.


I don't feel threatened by anti-adoption or feel pity for anti-adoption folks any more. They are what they are, people in pain.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
I do feel threatened, but not personally. There is damage to be done and children do suffer when adoption stops. I'm mom to two Cambodian-born kids, lucky enough to not get caught up in the suspension. I've seen what keeping families from the possibility of children has done to the kids stuck in orphanages.
Pro-adoption people must be at least as vociferous in touting their views as the anti- folks are. We are entitled to our opinions and the actions that go with.
PermalinkPermalink 03/01/06 @ 22:59
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
The anti-adoption folks are out of control, and I dislike them intensely.

But I did want to make one point about your statement:

"Someone else has to lose for me to adopt. But it is not my fault that someone else failed to parent his or her child. And that is the part that rubs me the wrong way."

Yes, you are right--it is not adoptive parents' fault that birthparents "failed."

But, consider this. Adoptive parents' money funds an industry that sometimes coerces women to relinquish their babies. I'm not talking about "failed" parents here, but women and men who could have been and would have been successful parents, had they not gotten tangled up with some agency or lawyer that told them they didn't deserve to parent, that the baby had to have a two-parent home, that they would be "selfish" to consider parenting.

I think that is what is at the root of the anti-adoption sentiment--that without the demand, there would be less supply.

If all adoptees were true orphans, the anti-adoption folks couldn't complain. But sometimes relinquishments are "manufactured" to fit demand.
PermalinkPermalink 03/02/06 @ 06:04
Comment from: Honestly, [Visitor]
Honestly? Truthfully? I just find some of it amusing. There's an over-the-top narcissism (even to the expense of the child) in much of the ranting. Sometimes, the farther it goes, the more entertaining it becomes.
PermalinkPermalink 03/02/06 @ 11:48
Comment from: a [Visitor]
Heather Lowe wrote:
"If all adoptees were true orphans, the anti-adoption folks couldn't complain."

With all due respect, yes they could. And often do. They often argue against adoptions of orphans from orphanages as well (domestic, foster care, and foreign; including ones where the initial birthgivers were either deceased or anonymous by their own volition).

The thing is, they may indeed have a point on a PERCENTAGE of the adoptions that go on in the western world --- although in this day and age, I also believe that percentage is much lower than in previous years. But their tunnel-vision, which so often encompasses anything within 100 feet of the mere word 'adoption', usually winds up over-shadowing any valid points they may have. They take a sledge-hammer to a situation that requires much more finesse, especially with regard to the public at large. But, as was so aptly stated, "they are what they are." (Shrug.)
PermalinkPermalink 03/02/06 @ 12:27
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
You decided that the anti-adoption folks aren't crazy, stupid, mentally ill, but, just in a great deal of pain, right? I wish instead of dismissing them after that, you had taken one more step. If you had, I believe you would find that they have some real legitimate gripes - issues that need to be addressed.

You need not feel threatened by the "anti-adoption" people, but, maybe you should seriously consider that adoption does need some changes. Making adoption better for our children SHOULD be everyone's concern.
PermalinkPermalink 03/02/06 @ 14:36
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to Ukraine Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 162